The questions, discussion topics, and author biography that follow are intended to enhance your group’s reading of Jonathan Harr’s A Civil Action. We hope they . 22 Sep In fact, it’s since become a valuable teaching tool for civil procedure professors. Jonathan Harr does an excellent job of providing a layperson’s. Free Essay: Jonathan Harr wrote a compelling novel, called A Civil Action, on the actual events of a thrilling court case involving two major corporations.

Author: Dojinn Kazimi
Country: Armenia
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Personal Growth
Published (Last): 1 March 2018
Pages: 500
PDF File Size: 3.43 Mb
ePub File Size: 10.1 Mb
ISBN: 923-1-99119-862-1
Downloads: 75762
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Shaktitaxe

Oh well, prepare for the real deal. November 14, Toronto Garr. While option 2 is still out there, I wouldn’t recommend it for people who had the same hopes I did with option 1.

I couldn’t put it down. The sickness case was revealed as Leukemia, which is Cancer, and some people are very concerned about this case.

A Civil Action by Jonathan Harr – Reading Guide –

Return to Book Page. Harr takes a different approach, starting his story with the actual victims of the toxic pollution before moving on to focus on the legal details. Schlichtmann originally decides not to take the case due to both the lack of evidence and a clear defendant. Jun 30, Krista rated it really liked it Shelves: Residents complain about the smell and taste of the water and are continually told that there is nothing wrong.

Should be required reading, not just in law schools, but all schools, period.

If you are looking to give feedback on our new site, please send it along to feedback globeandmail. Grace that knowingly dumped acction carcinogens including trichloroethylene.

A Civil Action by Jonathan Harr

Litigation is full of highs and lows. If you want to write a letter to the editor, please forward to letters globeandmail. Colors seem brighter, food tastes better, the weather is of compelling interest. Sep 08, Moira Russell rated it really liked it Shelves: The book concerns a leukemia “cancer cluster” of half a dozen children that popped up in the mids, in Woburn, Massachusetts, about half an hour North of Boston.

The jury finds Beatrice not liable. And many describe the process of making partner as a pie-eating contest in which first prize is more pie. This experience can be intoxicating for some, but it can also be profoundly disorienting. I’m a print subscriber, link to my account Subscribe to comment Why do I need to subscribe? Despite the author’s evident hero-worship, I found Schlichtmann obnoxious and unprofessional throughout.


Fast forward to the late 80’s and early 90’s when Schlictman and his crew try to find a link between very sick and dying people and the dumping of toxic waste whic This is the true story of a nine year legal battle involving flamboyant, obsessed and ambitious lawyer, Jan Schlictmann, and two large corporations accused of exposing a cluster of mostly children to water contaminated by industrial pollution.

Harr suggests that perhaps the case was one “that the judicial system was not equipped to handle” [p. There were resources that the water could turn out to be unsafe and uncleaned, especially The choice book that i am reading is titled, “A Civil Action” which is by the author, Jonathan Harr.

A Civil Action is real-life courtroom drama fit for a beach read

Such an outcome is devastating to plaintiffs who count on the jury being swayed by human nature to err on the side of jonathsn on the causation issue due to the obvious and awful effects of leukemia on its victims and their families. In a suit for environmental contamination or med malpractice or products liability the expenses for experts can rapidly reach astronomical proportions.

How important is personal honor to each of them, in the face of possibly losing their jobs? Law school advertises itself aaction teaching students to ” think like a lawyer. Unbound Worlds Exploring the science fiction and fantasy universe. Fast forward to the late 80’s and early 90’s when Schlictman and his crew try to find a link between very sick and dying people and the dumping of toxic waste which entered the ground water and well system of the town.

The story actoin sometimes cited as an illustration of how our legal system has gone “awry”.

A Civil Action Reader’s Guide

The lawyer, however, is living large, buying a Porsche, expensive suits, and booking expensive hotel conference rooms and catered meals to conduct negotiations with opposing council, all of which are billed as expenses to be deducted from any future settlement the victims acton receive. You must see the movie!


Do you agree with any of her complaints? And my colleagues are very tolerant of my writing compulsion. Jonthan is easy to miss the lesson of this very interesting book.

Highly recommended if you’re intrigued by civil litigation or environmental contamination. In Woburn, Massachusetts not far from Boston in the s, a cluster or a particular area with a high incidence of leukemia developed. When he hears about the lawsuit, Jack Riley is outraged. When the defense filed its Rule 11 motion against the plaintiffs, Schlictmann got personally offended at the tactic, a response that colored his strategy going into a crucial hearing.

So this book was exciting and emotional. Specifically, in this bifurcated trial, the issue of causation was tried to the jury first, wherein the jury would determine if, by a preponderance of the evidence, the defendants’ pollution “proximately caused” the leukemia instances. The job market for entering lawyers is worse than ever.

Tuition is more expensive than ever. The details of the case occupy every waking hour and usually intrude into dreams as well. The only individuals who dare take a stand against these corporations, men with unshakable notions of maintaining justice like Schlictmann, are ultimately bound for failure. As stated previously, A Civil Action ends on a deceptively happy note.

Instead the focus tends to be on statistics, the financial impact, and how politicians will react to the event. The efforts he went to to try to prove two major companies responsible are amazing in themselves and in how they are portrayed by Harr.

By contrast, Beatrice Foods and W. Is he so obliged?

Instead Schlictmann goes out rather pathetically, losing all of his material stability and status. Representing the bereaved parents is an unlikely Don Jonzthan Harr begins his account by introducing his audience to Anne Anderson, a woman living in Woburn, Massachusetts whose son Jimmy contracts leukemia.